Home / Sales / When Should You Follow Up with a Potential Customer

When Should You Follow Up with a Potential Customer

Ever wondered if your follow-up email disappeared into a digital black hole? 😩 You’re not alone. Following up with potential customers is more science than guesswork-and timing is everything. Whether you’re selling insurance in Sydney or software in Brisbane, understanding *when* to reach out can mean the difference between a deal and dead air.

Key Takeaways

  • Strike fast: Following up within 5 minutes boosts your chances of connecting by 900%.
  • Be persistent, not annoying: A structured 14-day cadence works better than one-and-done messages.
  • Time it right: Tuesday to Thursday, between 10–11am or 4–5pm (local time), is your sweet spot.
  • Follow the rules: In Australia, unsolicited calls are only legal between 9am–8pm on weekdays.
  • Use tech smartly: Automate your follow-ups without sounding like a robot.

Why Timing Matters More Than You Think

Research from Harvard Business Review found that companies responding to leads within 5 minutes are 10 times more likely to make contact than those waiting even 30 minutes. In short: if you snooze, you lose.

Think of it this way: if someone’s looking at your website, they’re in the mood to talk. Wait too long, and they’ll move on-possibly to your competitor.⏳

“The best time to follow up is when you’re still on their mind-not when you’re an afterthought.”

The Golden Hour: Speed-to-Lead Principles

That first hour after a customer expresses interest is gold. Here’s a winning formula:

  • 0–5 mins: Automated confirmation email + quick phone call (if details are available)
  • Within 30 mins: Connect on LinkedIn or send a personalised video
  • Within 60 mins: Short value-driven email or SMS

Yes, it might sound like a lot-but if your CRM and automation tools are set up right, it’s a breeze. And your conversion rates will thank you for it!

Follow-Up Cadence: The 14-Day Rule

Not everyone is ready to buy on Day One. But they might be ready on Day Fourteen. That’s why a structured follow-up plan is essential.

Here’s a sample 14-day sequence to keep your lead warm without turning them off:

  1. Day 1: Call + voicemail + email (your first touch trio)
  2. Day 2: Follow-up email with added value (e.g. whitepaper, case study)
  3. Day 4: LinkedIn message or social touch
  4. Day 7: Email or SMS with a relevant offer or testimonial
  5. Day 14: Final check-in or “break-up” email

Space things out to avoid sounding like a clingy ex-unless you’re dating your CRM. 😅

Best Days & Times to Follow Up in Australia

Yes, timing varies by industry and persona. But across the board, studies (UpLead, HubSpot) show the following:

  • Best Days: Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday
  • Best Times: 10–11am or 4–5pm local time

Why? Mondays are for catching up and Fridays are for clocking off. Midweek mornings and late arvos hit the productivity sweet spot.

Mind the Rules: Legal Guidelines in Australia

Before you go dialing and DMing, know the legal lay of the land:

  • Cold calls: Only between 9am–8pm on weekdays, and 9am–5pm on Saturdays (no Sundays or public holidays).
  • Emails and SMS: Must include opt-out links and be sent only to contacts who’ve given consent.

Violating these? That’s a fast track to a fine and a fuming customer. Always follow the ACMA guidelines.

Conclusion: Your Follow-Up Strategy Matters

Following up is part art, part science, and a dash of comic timing. Get it right, and you’re not just contacting customers-you’re closing deals. Implement a thoughtful cadence, respect your lead’s schedule, and make the most of those golden first few minutes.

Now’s the time to audit your current follow-up approach and optimise it before your competitors do! 😉

References

Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
Reddit